In her offering of “Miss Extreme Congeniality,” Erin McCarthy pens an emotionally complex tale that is punctuated by moments of unexpected humor. C.J. White and Wyatt Maddock are FBI partners working together on an insider trading case for the Bureau. Wyatt is a sexy, untamed playboy, and CJ hates him because she wants him. To quote her, “He was testosterone in a tux and she was boring in baggy.” Their working relationship has deteriorated to the point where it is impossible for them to work together as Wyatt has made it abundantly clear that he wants her, too.
Wyatt makes her a deal. If C.J. will spend one night with him and wear whatever he wants her to, then he will transfer to another field office. C.J. longs for the chance to be with Wyatt but also believes that it is impossible for them to have a relationship, so she agrees. What happens between them is more than either one of them bargains for, but C.J. has secrets that may ultimately keep them apart. It is up to Wyatt to make her realize that this man in black tie, is indeed the man of her dreams.